fbpx

REI Merino 185 Long-Sleeve Crew Base Layer Review

SaveSavedRemoved 0
Deal Score0
Deal Score0


A male hiker wearing a baseball cap, sunglasses, long-sleeve grey shirt, and a backpack with a clipped device stands in a dry, grassy mountain meadow with a dense pine forest and rolling hills in the background under a cloudy blue sky.

Bottom Line

The REI Merino 185 Long-Sleeve Crew (men’s / women’s) is a classic, no-frills 100%-merino wool top that delivers impressive four-season versatility at a sub-$100 price point. Weighing just 6.8 ounces on our scale, it hits the sweet spot for midweight warmth: lighter and more breathable than winter-specific hoodies but noticeably warmer than thin, three-season synthetics. In our controlled wicking tests, its 100% merino knit dispersed moisture faster and wider than blended competitors, pulling sweat away from the skin to prevent post-climb chills.

REI kept the design intentionally simple: There are no thumb loops, chest pockets, or hood, and the cut is relaxed enough to wear comfortably as a standalone camp shirt when you shed outer layers. Like many pure merino garments, it has a slight initial wool itch out of the package that softens over time, and its exterior seams are raised rather than flat-locked as advertised – though we never felt them chafe on the trail.

If you want a dependable, odor-resistant natural-fiber layer you can wear year-round without overspending, the REI Merino 185 is one of the best values in our best base layers gear guide.

How We Tested

We tested the REI Merino 185 Long-Sleeve Crew on trail in temperatures ranging from the 50s to the 70s Fahrenheit. We spent multiple nights sleeping in the shirt at camp and wore it casually for several weeks. We weighed the shirt on our scale and conducted a 30-minute timed spray-bottle moisture-wicking comparison alongside competing base layers.

Quick Specs

  • Fabric: 100% merino wool
  • Style: Crew neck

REI Merino 185 Long-Sleeve Crew

Best Value Four-Season Merino Base Layer


CleverHiker Rating:

4.2/5.0


Price:

$85


Measured Weight:

6.8 oz.


Fabric/Weight:

Midweight merino wool

Pros

  • Excellent moisture wicking prevents post-hike chills
  • Lightweight build offers true four-season versatility
  • Relaxed fit works well under layers or on its own
  • Naturally odor-resistant
  • Great value at under $100

Cons

  • Initial wool itch softens slightly after multiple washes but never fully disappears
  • No thumb loops, zippers, or pockets
  • Seams bump out slightly, though we never felt them chafe

A male hiker wearing a grey long-sleeve shirt, dark shorts, a blue baseball cap, and sunglasses bends over in a dry alpine meadow to adjust the shoulder strap of an olive green backpack. The background features a sparse forest of evergreen trees and a bright sky with scattered clouds.
The REI Merino 185 Long-Sleeve Crew looks clean enough to wear on its own around camp or town. – Photo Credit: Brett Kretzer (CleverHiker.com)

Comfort

The REI Merino 185 offers solid, everyday comfort anchored by a relaxed, forgiving cut. Unlike compression-style base layers that feel painted on when you take off your mid-layer at camp, the REI’s looser fit makes it easy to wear as a standalone long-sleeve shirt.

Out of the box, the 100% merino wool fabric has that familiar, slight wool itchiness. While it softens noticeably after several wash cycles, sensitive skin will feel a bit of texture early in the garment’s lifespan. We also noticed that the seams bump out slightly on the exterior rather than using a true flat-lock stitch, though the interior felt smooth and never caused irritation during our hikes or while sleeping.

Comfort Score: 4.1 / 5.0

Close-up shot of a male hiker wearing a light gray Icebreaker Oasis Long Sleeve Crewe merino wool shirt while standing outdoors with a blurred meadow and forest background.
The Merino 185 has a looser, relaxed fit for easy mobility and comfort. – Photo Credit: Brett Kretzer (CleverHiker.com)

Warmth

With a 185-gram-per-square-meter merino knit, this top lands squarely in the versatile middle ground for warmth. It isn’t built to rival heavyweight winter competitors or hooded balaclava tops, nor does it have a collar zip to trap extra heat around the neck. 

Instead, it provides reliable core insulation that takes the edge off crisp summer mornings while layering effortlessly under a fleece and puffy in the winter. In our side-by-side comparison, it felt noticeably warmer than the Smartwool Classic All-Season Crew while checking in at virtually the same weight.

Warmth Score: 4.2 / 5.0

Close-up of a person stretching the light gray fabric of a long-sleeve merino wool shirt between their hands to demonstrate its elasticity and transparency, with an outdoor grassy background blurred in the distance.
the Merino 185 is best suited for cool mornings and shoulder-season hiking. – Photo Credit: Brett Kretzer (CleverHiker.com)

Moisture Management & Breathability

Moisture management is where the REI Merino 185 truly shines. In our spray-bottle test, an eight-inch circle of water applied to the fabric expanded by 25% within 10 minutes and reached 37.5% dispersion by 20 minutes, outpacing the blended Ridge Merino Aspect and drying slightly faster as well.

Because the 100% merino fibers spread moisture out across a broad surface area rather than letting sweat pool in one saturated spot, the fabric pulls dampness away from your skin and prevents that cold, clammy feeling when you stop moving. Combined with its breathable midweight knit, it regulates temperature well across aerobic hikes and cool evenings.

Moisture Management & Breathability Score: 4.6 / 5.0

Close-up of a hiker wearing a light gray REI Co-op lightweight merino wool t-shirt with flatlock seams and the REI logo near the hem, outdoors with a blurry natural landscape in the background.
The 100%-merino build offers exceptional breathability and moisture wicking. – Photo Credit: Brett Kretzer (CleverHiker.com)

Weight & Packability

Tipping our scale at just 6.8 ounces, the REI Merino 185 is light enough to disappear into a backpacking pack without second-guessing. It weighs 1.5 ounces less than the hooded Ridge Merino Aspect and nearly 3 ounces less than the synthetic REI Midweight Half-Zip, making it an easy grab for multi-day backpacking trips where every ounce counts.

Weight & Packability Score: 4.5 / 5.0

A male hiker wearing a cap, sunglasses, long-sleeve grey shirt, and black shorts stands in an open meadow with dry grass, holding a black backpack. In the background are rolling hills covered in evergreen trees under an overcast sky.
the REI Merino 185 Crew has an initial itchiness but softens up a bit over time. – Photo Credit: Brett Kretzer (CleverHiker.com)

Features & Versatility

If you are looking for technical bells and whistles – like thumb loops, a chest pocket, or a quarter-length zipper – you won’t find them here. The REI Merino 185 is simply a clean, well-executed crew-neck shirt.

What it lacks in extra features, however, it more than makes up for in year-round versatility. Because it isn’t overly heavy or encumbered by a hood, you can wear it on chilly summer nights in the alpine, throughout the shoulder seasons, and as an odor-resistant base layer in the dead of winter.

Features & Versatility Score: 4.4 / 5.0

Close-up shot of a hiker standing on a dry dirt trail, wearing a grey long-sleeve sun hoodie and dark hiking shorts, with their long shadow cast on the ground to the right.
No thumb loops, just a simple and comfortable wristband. – Photo Credit: Brett Kretzer (CleverHiker.com)

Should You Buy the REI Merino 185 Long-Sleeve Crew?

If you want a single, natural-fiber base layer that can handle all four seasons without breaking the bank, the REI Merino 185 Long-Sleeve Crew is an easy recommendation. It beats higher-priced competitors like the Smartwool Classic All-Season in warmth and pure merino comfort while wicking moisture efficiently on the trail. Just keep in mind that it benefits from a few washes to soften the initial wool feel and skips extras like thumb loops.

A male hiker stands outdoors wearing a grey long-sleeve shirt, dark shorts, sunglasses, a cap, and a backpack. He is captured from a low angle against a backdrop of distant green pine trees and a partly cloudy blue sky, showcasing how the backpack rests comfortably on his back.
The fabric wicks sweat and dries quickly, so it didn’t feel clammy during hard efforts. – Photo Credit: Brett Kretzer (CleverHiker.com)

What Other Base Layers Should You Consider?

Smartwool Classic All-Season Review: The Classic All-Season is a longtime thru-hiking favorite. However, in our testing, the REI Merino 185 delivered better warmth and a 100% merino build (versus Smartwool’s nylon-core blend) for less money.

Icebreaker Merino 200 Oasis Review: The Merino Oasis 200 offers very similar midweight 100% merino performance, though the REI Merino 185 matches its on-trail utility at a lower price point.

REI Midweight Half-Zip Review: Our top budget pick if you prefer synthetic fabrics, the REI Midweight Half-Zip runs slightly warmer and adds a half-zip for venting, though it lacks the REI Merino 185’s natural odor resistance and superior moisture wicking.

A side-profile shot of a hiker with sunglasses and a baseball cap wearing a grey long-sleeve sun hoodie, standing in a dry mountain meadow with a distant forested hillside under a blue sky.
Underarm gussets allow for full range of motion when reaching for trekking poles or a pack strap. – Photo Credit: Brett Kretzer (CleverHiker.com)

The post REI Merino 185 Long-Sleeve Crew Base Layer Review appeared first on CleverHiker.



Source link

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Offroadbargains
Logo
Enable registration in settings - general
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare